Island Home Realty
Share
With over $100 million+ in sales, we've helped clients discover everything from charming sunset cottages to luxury waterfront estates.
07/01/2026
At 1033 Catherine Street, timeless Key West architecture meets refined modern design—where soaring ceilings, warm natural materials, custom finishes, and seamless indoor-outdoor living create a home that feels both sophisticated and effortlessly livable.
From the chef’s kitchen to the private saltwater pool and spa, every space has been curated with intention.
3 Bedrooms | 3.5 Bathrooms | Nearly 1,900 SF
Presented by Paige Bethel
Island Home Realty
📞 305.395.0550
POV: You finally found the Old Town home you’ve been waiting for. 🌴
Beautifully restored and completely turnkey, 1033 Catherine Street blends timeless Key West character with modern island living.
✨ 3 Bedrooms | 3.5 Bathrooms
🌿 Saltwater Pool & Spa
🍃 Off-Street Parking
📍 X Flood Zone
🏡 Offered Fully Furnished
This is Old Town living at its best.
📍1033 Catherine Street, Key West
💲$2,385,000
Interested in a private showing? Contact me!
Paige Bethel | Island Home Realty
📞 305-395-0550
06/29/2026
.
✨ Just Listed | 1033 Catherine Street | $2,385,000
A timeless Old Town retreat, thoughtfully restored for effortless island living. This beautifully reimagined 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers nearly 1,900 square feet of inviting living space, complete with a first-floor primary suite, chef’s kitchen, and designer finishes throughout.
Enjoy seamless indoor-outdoor living with a newly remodeled saltwater pool & spa, Ipe decking, lush tropical landscaping, off-street parking, and a desirable X Flood Zone location.
Offered fully furnished and completely turnkey.
📞 Paige Bethel | Island Home Realty
305-395-0550
IslandHomeRealty
🌅 NEW LISTING | 1709 Sunrise Drive | $1,295,000
Wake up to endless ocean views, breathtaking sunrises, and the waterfront lifestyle that makes the Florida Keys so special.
Situated on a rare 17,000 SF open-water lot in Tropical Bay Estates, this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of privacy, coastal charm, and effortless boating access. From the light-filled interiors and impact windows and doors to the serene primary suite overlooking the water, every detail is designed to showcase the incredible surroundings.
⚓ 2 protected cut-in boat slips
⚓ 110' concrete seawall
⚓ Direct ocean & backcountry access
🌊 Open-water views toward Bahia Honda
🏝 Quiet dead-end street location
Spend your days fishing, diving, boating, or simply soaking in the turquoise waters from your own backyard. Opportunities like this, with protected dockage, direct ocean access, and this much land are becoming increasingly rare in the Lower Keys.
📍 Big Pine Key, Florida
📲 Schedule your private showing today and discover your dream waterfront retreat.
05/20/2026
Congratulations to our buyers on their new home in beautiful Key West! 🌴☀️ It was such a pleasure guiding them through the process, and we’re excited to officially welcome them to island life in the Florida Keys.
Thinking about buying or selling in the Keys? Let the team at Island Home Realty help you make your next move!
📞 305-395-0550
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Telephone
Website
Address
33040
